The football world has been as hectic as ever during the first quarter of 2025, which means that our ever-increasing number of football tipsters have been kept busier than ever in providing their best value bets.
Many of them have maintained an impressive level of consistency over the first three months of the year, and we've our First XI together for you in our Best Football Tipster rankings, all listed for your convenience to help you to make an informed decision about which services are more than just a one-month wonder.
Just click on the links for more information about each tipster, and for details of any trial deals that are currently on offer.
11th FootballProfits
- 135 tips, 8.0% ROI, £215 Profit
- Preferred market: BTTS
The increasingly popular Both Teams To Score-No market has been expertly exploited by FootballProfits, who has been happily living up to his profile name since first appearing on Tipstrr at the back end of 2023.
After finishing fifth on our monthly leaderboard in January (having topped it in September), Football Profits has refined his once-prolific output into something much more manageable, with that reduction helping achieve a 43% win rate at odds of 6/4, which is always an equation that creates a profitable outcome.
10th Winning Tipsters
- 324 tips, 9.2% ROI, £594 Profit
- Preferred market: Various
In tenth place, Winning Tipsters wouldn’t claim to have been ripping up trees so far this year, but what he has done is to have strung three straight profitable months together to accrue a solid 9% yield over the first quarter.
His output of 20-30 selections per week are more or less split 50-50 between the 1X2 and Overs markets, and a 52% strike rate at average odds around the 5/4 mark suggest a discerning eye for value that looks designed to create long-term growth.
8th Footy Value Man
- 687 tips, 11.8% ROI, £1,615 Profit
- Preferred market: Mainly 1X2 outsiders + exotics
For punters who like to back the underdog across various betting formats, then Footy Value Man might tick all the right boxes with his rich selection of 1X2 Match Winner bets, laced with Correct Score bets, exotic multiple bets and the occasional acca.
Indeed, it has been those judiciously constructed combination bets that have provided the bulk of FVM’s profits so far this year, with 30 over his 110 multiple tips accruing some returns at combined odds comfortably above 20/1.
7th Totally
- 84 tips, 12.9% ROI, £216 Profit
- Preferred market: Over/Under
The Over/Under market is becoming an increasingly popular target for discerning tipsters, so if you prefer betting on the amount of goals scored rather than trying to pick the match winner, then the recent form of Totally might merit your attention.
That strategy hit the ground running with January’s tasty 30% ROI, and although the next two months could not quite reach the same level of performance, the profit line continued on an upward trajectory to lock in a solid 13% yield over the quarter’s 84 selections.
6th TriBTTS
- 257 tips, 14.3% ROI, £736 Profit
- Preferred market: Both Teams To Score + Trixies
It’s no surprise to see TriBTTS making an appearance on this shortlist, as it’s only been three months since he was crowned 2024’s Best Football Tipster, thanks to a niche strategy of combining his Both Teams To Score singles into potentially more lucrative trixie bets.
After kicking off the year with an unexpected drawdown month, it was back to profitable business as usual in February, before going on to earn a top-three spot among March’s Best Football Tipsters with a 30% monthly yield, cementing his place as one of Tipstrr’s most popular football services.
6th Manovacia
- 62 tips, 14.7% ROI, £182 Profit
- Preferred market: Mainly Asian Handicap
In sixth place, Manovacia is a relative newcomer to the Tipstrr community, but boasts two solid years of fully verified success on the Pyckio platform, and he has migrated both his service and his form seamlessly across ten consecutive months of profitable growth.
Preferring to be measured by the quality of his low-volume selections rather than their quantity, this easily manageable service enjoyed a whopping 75% win rate throughout February and March, thanks to his expertise in the 1X2 and Asian Handicap markets.
5th Gunslinger
- 273 tips, 15.0% ROI, £819 Profit
- Preferred market: 1X2 Match Winner (above evens)
One of the newest services to make this top ten, Gunslinger made an immediate impact after launching his simple 1X2 Match Winner service back in December, and has continued to go from strength to strength so far this year.
The first three months of 2025 have yielded a rock solid 15% ROI, equating to more than £800 in clear profit, all courtesy of an astute knowledge of the sport that has allowed him to enjoy a 48% success rate at picking out match winners priced well above the even-money line.
4th Almma
- 71 tips, 17.1% ROI, £242 Profit
- Preferred market: 1X2
Launched back in September last year, it took the straightforward 1X2 service of Almma a while to bed in, but four months of double-digit gains later and it looks like we have an uber-selective tipster with a simple formula for profitable success.
While clearly favouring the Draws market, Almma has not shied away from Match Winner bets when the value is there, and if you prefer the liquidity offered by Pinnacle’s prices, then this service might be a pathway towards achievable long-term growth.
3rd Mix Mogul Football
- 121 tips, 20.3% ROI, £490 Profit
- Preferred market: BTTS
It’s just over a year since Mix Mogul Football kickstarted his tenure on Tipstrr with five straight profitable months, and he has begun 2025 in similar fashion, backing up January’s best-yet 47% monthly yield with less spectacular but no less admirable returns in February (22%) and March (6%), to keep his profit line following a long-term upward trajectory.
Focusing almost exclusively on the BTTS-No market, MMF is clearly not afraid to go against the bookmakers’ trends, with average advised odds of almost 2/1 dovetailing nicely with a sustained 45% win rate to add almost £500 to the betting bank so far this year.
2nd Pinnacle Bets
- 67 tips, 23.5% ROI, £315 Profit
- Preferred market: Asian Handicap
Another promising recent acquisition from the Pyckio platform, our runner-up PinnacleBets has yielded a double-digit return on investment in each of his first six months of service, culminating in both February and March accruing an identical 27.9% ROI.
As the service name suggests, PinnacleBets focuses solely on the optimum liquidity provided by Pinnacle’s markets, and especially in Asian Handicap bets across a broad spectrum of European football competitions.
Boasting a 58% win rate and a 23% ROI during the first quarter of 2025, PinnacleBets looks designed to provide achievable long-term growth, and is currently offering a tasty 30% first-month discount for any new subscribers who value quality over quantity.
1st Footy Star
- 90 tips, 20.6% ROI, £468 Profit
- Preferred market: BTTS
Of all the tipsters to have ventured into the increasingly popular BTTS-No market, few have achieved as much sustained success as Footy Star, whose 50% success rate at average advised odds of 6/4 has been enough to sustain a 20% ROI since the turn of the year, adding over £450 to the kitty.
Successive appearances in our monthly Best Tipster rankings for February (25% ROI) and March (15%) were deserved recognition of a sustained spell of profitable consistency that followed on from similar eye-catching gains in December (31%) and January (54%).
A moderate supply of just 5-10 tips per week are invariably published between 8pm and midnight the evening before matches kick off the following day, providing a simple manageable service designed to eliminate stress from the betting process.
The profit graph on Footy Star’s stats page displays a tell-tale climbing straight line, a surefire indicator of this tipster's remarkable performance either side of the New Year - and the good news is that he’s currently offering a whopping 70% first-month discount for new subscribers.
So, well done again to Footy Star for topping such a high-quality honours board, and well done also to the many tipsters who are flying just below the radar of our shortlist, but who are showing the kind of consistency that should see them challenging for a top ten finish in the very near future.
Please note: Any discount offer is for the first month of new memberships only, and cannot be claimed more than once, nor is it available for existing members.
- Profits calculated to level £20 stakes